Email lists are like gardens—they need regular care. If you ignore them for too long, the weeds of inactivity start to creep in, and you risk losing healthy growth.
In email marketing terms, those weeds are disengaged subscribers—people who once opened, clicked, and cared about your content but now barely notice your emails.
The instinct might be to go full throttle and blast them with attention-grabbing campaigns, but here’s the catch: waking up your sleeping audience the wrong way can hurt your sender reputation and your email deliverability. That means even the subscribers who do want to hear from you might never see your emails.
So how do you reconnect with these subscribers without ending up in the dreaded spam folder? Let’s walk through a proven, safe approach—one that keeps your deliverability intact while giving your old subscribers a genuine reason to re-engage.
Why This Matters Right Now
Email service providers (ESPs) are getting smarter at filtering out unwanted content. They look at your open rates, click rates, and spam complaints to decide whether your emails belong in the inbox or the spam tab.
If you suddenly send a high volume of emails to disengaged subscribers, they’re more likely to delete or ignore your messages. Worse, some may mark you as spam. This sends a red flag to ESPs and lowers your deliverability across the board.
The good news? With a thoughtful, data-driven re-engagement plan, you can breathe life back into your subscriber list while keeping your sender reputation healthy.
Step-by-Step: How to Re-engage Safely
1. Segment Before You Send
Not all disengaged subscribers are created equal. Some might have stopped opening your emails a month ago; others might have been silent for a year.
Here’s what to do:
- Create segments based on inactivity length (e.g., 30 days, 90 days, 6+ months).
- Focus on the most recently disengaged first—they’re easier to win back.
- Keep your longest-inactive subscribers for last, and approach cautiously.
How MailDrip.io helps:
Our segmentation tools let you filter by last open date, click activity, or custom engagement scores—so you’re only targeting the people most likely to respond positively.
2. Start with a Low-Volume Test
Before you blast thousands of old contacts, send a smaller re-engagement campaign to a small portion of your inactive list. Monitor:
- Open rate
- Click-through rate
- Spam complaints
If engagement is decent and complaints are low, you can slowly scale up.
3. Craft an Honest “We Miss You” Message
Skip the gimmicks. Instead, send a simple, human message acknowledging the gap and offering value. For example:
- Remind them why they subscribed in the first place.
- Share what’s new—maybe you’ve improved your content, added a new product, or started offering something more relevant to their needs.
- Include a clear, single call to action.
Pro tip: Make the subject line personal and warm, not clickbaity. Something like:
“Still want to hear from us?” or “Let’s reconnect—here’s what’s new.”
4. Give Them a Reason to Re-engage
If someone hasn’t opened your emails in months, they need a reason to start again. Offer:
- Exclusive content or resources
- A discount or early access
- A personal update or story they can connect with
The goal isn’t to bribe—it’s to remind them of the value you provide.
Take Your Emails to the Next Level
MailDrip helps you automate your outreach, nurture leads, and grow your brand with ease. Send the right message at the right time—without the stress.
Sign Up FreeNo Card Required
5. Make It Easy to Say “No”
It sounds counterintuitive, but giving subscribers an easy opt-out actually improves your deliverability. If they’re no longer interested, it’s better for them to unsubscribe than to stay on your list and hurt your engagement rates.
Add a prominent unsubscribe link, and even consider including a “reduce frequency” option.
6. Automate the Re-engagement Sequence
Instead of sending one email and calling it a day, build a short automation:
- Email 1: Friendly reintroduction + value offer
- Email 2: Reminder + alternative content format (e.g., short video, quick tips)
- Email 3: Final call before removal
If they engage at any step, move them back into your active segment.
How MailDrip.io helps:
With our drip automation, you can set up this sequence once and let it run on autopilot—no manual sending required.
7. Monitor Deliverability Metrics Closely
Keep an eye on:
- Open and click rates
- Bounce rates
- Spam complaints
If you notice negative trends, slow down your sending and refine your targeting. Your reputation is worth protecting.
8. Remove the Truly Inactive
At the end of your re-engagement campaign, remove anyone who hasn’t responded. It might feel like you’re losing potential customers, but keeping them will hurt your future inbox placement more than help.
With a cleaner list, your engagement rates improve, your deliverability rises, and your remaining subscribers get a better experience.
FAQs
How long should I wait before trying to re-engage someone?
For most businesses, 90 days of inactivity is a good benchmark. But if your emails go out infrequently, adjust accordingly.
Will removing inactive subscribers hurt my list size too much?
List size matters less than list quality. A smaller, engaged list will outperform a large, unresponsive one in both revenue and deliverability.
Should I use a different sending domain for re-engagement emails?
Not necessarily. If you segment carefully and start small, you can send from your main domain. Only consider a separate domain if your inactive list is very large.
Can re-engagement campaigns be evergreen?
Yes. With automation, new subscribers who go inactive can be automatically placed in a re-engagement flow without extra work.
Bringing It All Together
Re-engaging subscribers is less about blasting people with “special offers” and more about respecting their inbox, reminding them of your value, and giving them a reason to care again. Done right, you can rekindle interest without triggering spam filters or damaging your sender reputation.
At MailDrip.io, we make it easy to segment your list, automate thoughtful re-engagement sequences, and track your deliverability so your emails keep landing where they should—right in the inbox. If you’ve been sitting on a cold list, maybe now’s the time to warm it back up.
What’s one simple step you could take today to reconnect with the subscribers you’ve been missing?
